No Name Pub

Dollar bills blanket nearly every inch of the walls and ceiling of this Big Pine Key dive, layered so thick in places that the original surfaces have disappeared. Some are neatly pinned. Others curl at the edges after years of humidity. Many are signed, dated, or decorated with messages from visitors who wanted to commemorate their visit. 

The building dates back to the 1930s and originally served as a general store, then a bait shop for local fishermen. For a few years, the upstairs storage room was even converted into a brothel, but after several years the brothel shuttered. (The fishermen were reported to be better looking than the ladies.) 

The space has since evolved into a bar and restaurant that’s one of The Keys’ most beloved hangouts. Locals and tourists alike line up for its quirky pizza toppings (Caribbean chicken, white shrimp, furry fish, etc.), crispy coconut shrimp, and smoked fish dip. Their homemade key lime pie—filled with whipped cream—often steals the show with its uniquely light and creamy texture.

The tradition of covering the walls with dollar bills started decades ago when patrons started leaving signed notes behind, pinning them up as souvenirs. Every so often, the staff removes portions of the bills and donates the proceeds to local charities, turning this strange tradition into something quietly generous.